Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Government Policies
The Telecommunications Act of 1996 provisions of the law emphasized the importance of public libraries serving as Internet access points for the communities they serve.
The Children's Internet Protection Act requires a library that receives certain types of E-rate and LSTA funds to filter Internet access in the library.
USA Patriot Act have wide-ranging implications for libraries including increases in the circumstances of records that can be searched, the allowance of tracing and searching though electronic communication, and the gag order placed on investigations.
From: P.T. Jager, Government Information Quarterly 23 (2006)
Legacy
Review
- Sufficient bandwidth and broadband
- Perpetuation of the digital divide of Internet access in libraries
- The role of libraries as e government access points
- Complexitiites of funding internet access
- Impacts and contradictions of filtering
- chilling effect of homewland security
- Sifficiency of conncetivity (# of workstations)
- Levels of Public access
- The need for training
- Continuing gaps in access
- Sources of fuding for techonlogy
- Qustions of public policy
Chatman's Theory: Information Poverty & Life in the Round
1. Secrecy
2. Deception
3. Risk-taking
4. Situational Relevance
Life in the Round:
1. Small world- The Projects and their members had their own little world and community built up in there.
2. Social norms- Their lifestyle and habits become the social norm.
3. Social types- their life seems normal and accepted becuase no one has any motivation to change it.
4. Worldview- they are not motivated to change their life and they won't cross their own boundaries until something TRAGIC happens. Their cousin, Tyrel, was shot, and once that happened, they decided they needed to change their life. So they were seeking information since it was critical, relevant, and their old life was no longer functioning.
Understanding digital inequality:comparing continued use behavioral models of the socio-economically advantaged & disadvantaged
How did computer use differ between disadvantaged (low-income) and advantaged (high-income) groups in this study?
-Hedonic outcomes were more influential for the disadvantaged than the advantaged (111).
-Personal network exposure was stronger for the advantaged than the disadvantaged (112).
-Perceived behavioral control, self efficacy, and availability only affected behavioral intention for the disadvantaged. Disadvantaged individuals still need to deal with psychological and material barriers that are not directly addressed by technology center interventions (112).
-The advantaged had a higher level of PC ownership than the disadvantaged (112).
Thoughts on Class
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
Final Exam
How did Elfreda Chatman’s theories about Information Poverty and Life in the Round match the experiences of the Collins family in the documentary Legacy?
Elfreda Chatman’s theories about information poverty explained way why information seeking behavior is like the way it is. One main way that her theories related to the Collins family in the documentary was the idea of people who are poor often view themselves of being devoid of any resources. With the mom and aunt in Legacy I believe both felt like there was no resources for them to get out of their situation. For example when the mom tried to get a job she was unable to do that because of the lack of resources such as childcare. When she asked for help none was provided.
Another Example of Chatman’s theories were the idea that deception and secrecy are both mechanisms used due to the mistrust of other people being able to provide useful information. An example of Legacy was the mistrust of the system that was provided to the family. The older members of the family often had a hard time trusting people to help them with getting through issues they had.
The other concept that Chatman brought up was the concept of the small world. This explained that life in the small world is something that is just understood and that’s the way it is. This was prevalent in the neighborhood that the Collins family was in. Things were expected to be a certain such as many from there were not expected to get out of that bad neighborhood, many were not expected to go to college, and drugs, violence and pregnancy at a young age were just considered the norm.
Week 14: Servon, Chapter 9 Toward a New Agenda
"Policy must work to close remaining divides, focusing specifically on the disabled, African-Americans, Latinos, and those living in rural and inner-city areas."
"Policy makers must create and expand programs to address the training and content dimensions of the digital divide."
"Policy makers at the state and local levels should also continue to use flexible federal funding sources..to support innovative programs that address the digital divide and simultaneously confront other issues such as the IT labor shortage and persistent poverty."
"Policy makers at all levels of government should view the digital divide as an issue that cuts across departments and programs; failure to do so will have the effect of continued fragmentation and lack of unified response."
Community Technology Centers (CTCs) pages: 227-228
the article gives 2 visions that people have CTCs..
The first is to use the CTCs as training institutions, family learning centers, and gathering places
The second is to use CTCs only to fill present voids in other institutions, meaning that once those voids are filled CTCs would not be necessary
..Servon says that on their own CTCs probably won't help fix the digital divide so they need to work with other organizations and it will be most realistic for CTCs to partner with CTOs, libraries, or schools to help institutionalize their goals and reach more people.
Primary and Secondary Schools: pages 228-229
"Rather than creating separate computer classes, teachers should be given incentives to learn about IT and integrate it into their existing curricula."
"Government programs can also create incentives for collaboration between the schools and local CTCs."
..it also says that programs that are designed to be "scalable and adapt to students needs,should be studied in order to understand and document their potential and limits." and that federal programs should be used to institutionalize programs in schools, which will make for more equal access.
Post-Secondary Education: page 229
(by post-secondary education they mean 4 year college, community college, community-based training programs, employer-led training, and for-profit post secondary schools)
"Schools need to have flexible curricula, provide after-program services, and be responsive to employers' changing needs"
..it also says that all of the different types of post-secondary schools should work together and share their successes with each other so they can all improve.
The Corporate Sector: page 230
"Investing in areas that have not benefited fully from the information society simultaneously promotes larger social goals and enhances corporations' bottom lines."
..it says that corporate support is needed to help but that it is complicated to do
Philanthropic Organizations: page 230
"All of the actors that support digital divide work - corporate, government, and philanthropic- should share learning more widely and figure out how to complement each other's work."
Libraries: pages 230-231
"Libraries and CTCs need to engage in information sharing of what they have learned thus far in terms of how to apply IT."
..just before this this quote it says that library staff have had training in information science, which is an extremely important skill for CTCs and many CTC staff members have not.
Community-building Organizations: page 231
"CBOs (community-building organizations) can use new technology to increase the scale of their work."
"These organizations also have the ability to do creative and flexible programming."
"One of the most important roles for the CBOs will be to share these lessons with policy makers so that they can learn from this grassroots work and employ it to influence policy."
Reading Race Online
The study mentioned in the study guide is interesting because the names of the students are given, which directly imply what race they are. In Burkhalter's study, individuals seemed to have 'screen names' that weren't their actual names that directly linked them to their race. However, this study shows that just because physical signs of race are not present from which to make judgments about others, names, the content of one's message, and one's word choice can be just as telling as one's physical attributes.
Reading 1 outline
Looked at Public Libraries and the Internet 2004 Survey
· Policy issues related to public libraries
o Suffiecienty of connectivity, levels of public access, need for training, continuing gaps in access, sources for funding for technology
o Method - Used web-based survey approach from director of library
· Study findings
o Public libraries provide internet connectivity for almost all US residents
§ 99.6% of libs connected to the internet
o progress due to:
§ federal grants for tech through Library Service & Tech Act (LSTA)
§ e-rate discounts for infracture and connectivity
§ public/private support, including Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation
o public libs reaching a plateau in terms of the number of public workstations available for use and that these workstations are not enough to meet demand (especially rural – less workstations, slower connections)
· Key policy issues
o Bandwith
§ Average bandwith to operate is increasing, libs must inc to keep up
o Digital divide v. digital inclusion
§ Digital divide – geographic location, race, income, other factors
§ Digital inclusion – focus on how many ppl are currently online
§ Still divide in US
· Considerable divides b/w rural and other libs
o Rural areas being left behind in terms of speed of connectivity and the broadband access
· Access to bandwith vary considerably state-to-state
· 85% of libs reported that there are times of day when there are an inadequate number of workstations available
· libs serving the populations that have the greatest need for internet access are the least able to meet demand for it
o expectation of public libraries as a universal access point
§ e-government: public library important link b/w them, the networked environment, and the govt
§ level of technology in some libs reaching a plateau
· endless upgrade cycle, tech support, maintence costs, space limitations
o funding internet access
§ connectivity, assess services, etc not a one-time investment
o filtering, CIPA, E-rate
§ Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA) requires libs that receive e-rate and LSTA funds to filter (if do not filter, don’t get $)
· Filters only disabled if adult patron asks for it
o Blocks health information, including sex health
o Hesitant to ask to remove filters
o Having to ask can simply limit internet use in general
o Homeland security
§ USA Patriot Act
· Battle of protecting patrons and monitoring patrons
· Act allows for survelliance of expanded records and gag order for librarians
· So libs not taking as many usage stats, but this is useful information, but the libs want to protect patron privacy
· Conclusion
o Public libs moving toward digital exclusion
o We must define quality public Internet access service provision with the public library context
Reading Race Online
The issues related to being racially identified online is the same as being racially identified in a non-virtual plane. Some people will hold biases, prejudices, and all sorts of other feelings about people of a certain ethnic origin, these beliefs will show when they are interacting with a person of that ethnicity. The only difference with the online environment is that you can have an identity to others that is different from how they would view you if they saw a picture of you. Online you are judged by your alignments on certain issues, by the way you compose your sentences, and by the words you choose. In this situation others will fit you to a stereotype based on the text rather than the skin color.
If people perceive you to be of a race they aren't particularly fond of, they will act accordingly. They will not be as friendly, personable, and tolerant. The service provided won't be as good. With race online it is possible for you to mask your true racial identity if your interactions online resemble that of another race. But in general there will be hatred, abuse, and intolerance vented by people, even moreso online because of the certain level of anonyminity.
Sorry if this was kind of all over the place. Here's what I believe to be the main issues in these: discriminiation, intolerance, verbal(textual?) abuse of others.
Monday, May 11, 2009
Jaeger Article
- Although nearly all terminals provide internet access, the problem lies in the quantity of terminals available. Many people were still not able to access the internet due to the fact there are simply too few terminals available to use. Also, providing access, and providing adequate access are two different things. True, many libraries provide access, yet there are many rural areas that are being left behind in terms of connectivity speed and bandwidth. Urban areas provide the highest connection speed and bandwidth. More and more bandwidth is being required to withstand the heavy traffic on the servers, and without federal funding, this is becoming increasingly more difficult to accomplish.
- The government has moved to a “digitally inclusive” standpoint, focusing on how many people are online rather than how many ARE NOT online, leading to decreases in funding. Funding needs to be continuous to keep up with advancing technologies.
- The Children's Internet Protection Act (CIPA) prevents access from much of the information available on the internet-asking for access to such banned information can be embarrassing and leads to less freedom.
Monday, May 4, 2009
Group 1 video
Group 2 participation
Group 1 Video Participation
Group 3 Participation
I thought this project was very unique and interesting. Being my first real college project, it was a refreshing change from papers and exams. Furthermore, it really made me think about the concepts that we covered and their real life effects. It was interesting for me because in doing this project I went to the Madison Public Library for the first time, and it was interesting to think could I gain value from the provided services? What if I needed to use the computers for school work; could I have performed all necessary information retrieval, aggregation, and creation tasks to investigate the multimedia resources recomended by my professors and research and write my papers? I probably could, but with time constraints on computer access and limited access to computer database conduits and software, it would be harder than using College Library, my laptop, or any of the other libraries on campus.
Studying the libraries made the material seem real. Being from an upper-middle class town, I have little experience with libraries that serve such a diverse community as the Madison Public Library does. Living in a town that has more taxes per capita than Madison, my first impression was that being an older facility, the Madison Central Library would be subpar. What I discovered was something in between a taj mahal and a "yellow palace," lacking in adequate computer resources for a library of that size, the Madison Public Library still offers a vast array of community resources and reserves to serve the community of Madison.
Overall, this project was a great capstone to LIS 202, and far more engaging than the numerous trade articles in the reader.
Group Three Project Participation
I really enjoyed working on the project, and seeing the Madison Public Library-Central Branch. Comparing the libraries and working with the group members was a fun activity and a nice wrap-up project before our final exam for the class.
Sunday, May 3, 2009
group 3 participation
Group 3- Participation
Thursday, April 30, 2009
Video Project - Group 4
Wednesday, April 29, 2009
Group Video Response
Tuesday, April 28, 2009
Tuesday, April 7, 2009
Horizontal Networks Vs. Vertical
First Industrial Revolution:
Beginning: In the late 18th century.
Key technologies: Printing press, steam engine (transportation), machinery
Archetpyical workplace: workshop
Organization: Master-apprentice-serf
Expansion: This period defined individuals by their social status. Either you were lucky to have been taken in as an apprentice and work your way up to a master, or you fell into the later category of a se.rf. Much of your income was dependent on your families, or with intelligence with a bit of luck.
For the later two I would like to quote another blog that I found had a useful definition of vertical and horizontal networks.
That blog: http://growchangelearn.blogspot.com/2007/04/vertical-and-horizontal-networks.html
The poster defines them as: "Vertical networks are confining, imposed and physical. Horizontal networks are expansive, self controlled and non-physical."
The second revolution was characterized by these vertical networks in the late 19th century with the creation of: electricity, internal combustion, telegraph, telephone. Jobs were mostly taken place in factories, where there was a since of a boss, and a boss' boss. Big individual, like Rockefeller, rose out of this era.
The third revolution was characterized by horizontal networks. The advent of the Internet allowed for a bit of equality between individuals. Albeit those left behind (our topic in this class). The author describes this through a quote by Jarobe written in 2001 as "what we have is not a an Internet economy but an information economy in which computers and the Internet play an essential enabling role."
I think the distinction of these two terms is important and may be important for our exam.